It’s one of the questions we get asked most often on our manager training, and it’s usually asked quietly, near the end of the day.
“Someone’s work has been slipping for a while. I finally raise it, and they tell me they’ve been struggling with anxiety. How do I know they’re not just playing the mental health card?”
It’s an honest question. Most managers who ask it aren’t cynical. They’re stuck. They want to be fair to the person in front of them, and fair to the rest of the team who have been picking up the slack. And they’re worried that if they say the wrong thing, they’ll either be unkind or get it wrong.
So here’s how we’d think about it.

The short answer
You usually can’t know for certain whether someone’s anxiety is behind their performance. And the good news is, you don’t have to.
Your job isn’t to decide whether the anxiety is real. Your job is to take what they’ve told you seriously, put the person first, get the right support in place, and only then look at the work again. If you do things in that order, it doesn’t matter as much whether you guessed right.
Why the suspicion shows up
It’s worth being honest about where the feeling comes from, because it’s very normal.
The timing feels convenient. The mental health part comes up at the exact moment the performance conversation starts. That can look like a shield.
But think about it from the other side. For a lot of people, the performance conversation is the first time anyone has asked. They may have been holding it together for months, telling nobody, hoping it would pass. Being asked about the work is often what finally makes them say it out loud.
You’ve seen it used before. Some managers have had a genuine bad experience, and that sticks.
You’re tired too. If you’ve been covering gaps and fielding complaints from the team, your patience is thinner. That’s human. It’s just worth noticing before you go into the room.

What you can’t do, and what you can
You can’t diagnose anxiety, and you shouldn’t try. You don’t need to see a doctor’s note before you treat what someone says with respect.
What you can do is look at what’s in front of you.
- What has changed in the work? Be specific. Which deadlines, which mistakes, since when.
- What has changed in the person? Have you noticed them quieter, more irritable, working odd hours, avoiding certain tasks?
- What’s normal for them? Someone who has been reliable for three years and has slipped in the last two months is telling you something different from someone who has always struggled with the role.
None of this proves anything either way. But it gives you a fair picture to talk from, rather than a hunch.
If anxiety comes up in the middle of the conversation
This is where a lot of managers freeze. Here’s a simple way through it.
1. Pause the performance part, don’t abandon it. Thank them for telling you. Something like: “Thanks for telling me that. I’m glad you did. Can you tell me a bit more about how things have been?”
2. Listen before you solve. You don’t need answers yet. You need to understand how long it’s been going on, how it’s affecting their work, and whether they’re getting any support.
3. Ask what would help. People often know what would make a difference. A change to their hours for a few weeks. Fewer meetings. Clearer priorities. Someone to check in with.
4. Let the performance conversation wait. Once someone has told you they’re struggling, this isn’t the meeting to set targets or talk about formal steps. The priority now is the person. If you carry on with the performance part as if nothing has been said, it can feel like pressure at the worst possible moment, and it can leave you and your organisation on shaky ground.
You can be honest that the work will need to be looked at together later. Something like: “Let’s focus on how you are first, and get the right support in place. We can look at the work together once that’s sorted.”
5. Agree what happens next. A date to check in again. Who else needs to be involved, such as HR or occupational health. What support you’ve agreed, written down so you both remember it the same way.
That’s not you letting them off. And it’s not you calling them a liar. It’s you looking after the person first, which is what makes a fair conversation about the work possible later.
Why support has to come first
If someone’s anxiety has a substantial and long term effect on their day to day life, it may count as a disability under the Equality Act 2010. You don’t have to decide that yourself, and you shouldn’t try. But it does mean the order matters.
Before any decisions are made about someone’s performance, there needs to be a proper look at whether reasonable adjustments would help. Things like changes to hours, workload, deadlines, where they work or how tasks are given out. Occupational health and HR can help with this.

Only once support and any adjustments have been in place for a fair amount of time does it make sense to look at performance again. If you go the other way round, you risk making things worse for the person, and you may also be treating them unfairly.
Alongside that, you have a duty of care. Someone who has just told you they’re struggling may need more than adjustments. Make sure they know where they can get support, such as their GP, an employee assistance programme if you have one, or occupational health.
“But what if they really are using it?”
Occasionally, someone might be. But it isn’t your job to catch them out, and treating everyone as a suspect does far more harm than good.
If support and any adjustments have been put in place, given a fair amount of time, and reviewed with HR and occupational health, and things still aren’t working, then you’re in a clearer position to look at the work again. Not because you’ve proved anything, but because you’ve done things in the right order and you’ve got a record of what was agreed.
What doesn’t work is deciding in your head that they’re “playing the card”, and then quietly treating them differently. That’s when things tend to end up in a grievance, a longer absence, or someone leaving, and nobody comes out of it well.
Fairness to the rest of the team
Managers often worry that supporting one person is unfair on everyone else. It’s a fair worry.
Support doesn’t mean the work disappears. It might mean a short term change to who does what, with a clear end date and a review. Your team doesn’t need to know the details of why. They need to know that the gap is being managed and that it won’t fall on them forever.
If several people in a team are struggling at once, it’s also worth stepping back and asking whether the problem is the workload, the pace of change, or the way the team is being led, rather than one person’s mental health.
When to involve HR or occupational health
Bring them in early rather than late. You don’t have to decide on your own whether someone’s anxiety counts as a disability under the Equality Act, or what adjustments are reasonable. That’s what HR and occupational health are there for.
Involve them when:
- the issue has gone on for more than a few weeks
- you’re thinking about formal performance steps
- someone has been off, or is likely to be off
- you’re unsure what adjustments are reasonable
And if at any point you’re worried about someone’s safety, that comes before everything else. Follow your organisation’s procedure and get support straight away.
The bit managers don’t often hear
Asking “are they playing the card?” doesn’t make you a bad manager. It usually means you care about getting it right.
The managers who handle this best aren’t the ones who always believe everyone, or the ones who believe nobody. They’re the ones who stay curious, keep talking, and write down what they’ve agreed.
We’ve written more about the first steps when performance drops and mental health might be part of it in Mental Health and Underperformance: What Managers Should Do First.
Common questions
Can I ask for proof that someone has anxiety? You can ask whether they’ve spoken to their GP or anyone else, and whether they’d be willing to see occupational health. That’s different from asking for proof before you’ll take them seriously. Talk to HR before asking for any medical information.
Can I still manage their performance? Having anxiety doesn’t mean the work can never be discussed. But support and reasonable adjustments come first, and HR should be involved before any formal steps. If the anxiety is a disability under the Equality Act, getting the order wrong can be unfair to the person and can put your organisation at risk.
What if they don’t want to talk about it? That’s okay. They don’t have to share details. You can still agree practical support and a date to check back in.
What if I said the wrong thing in the moment? Go back and say so. “I don’t think I handled our chat very well the other day. Can we try again?” It goes a long way.
Help your managers feel ready for this conversation
Our Managing Mental Health in the Workplace course gives managers the confidence to notice changes, start the conversation, and know where their role ends and HR, occupational health or specialist support begins. We run it online and in person across Scotland, and can tailor it to your teams.
Book a free call to talk about what your managers need.